Steel vs Wood Fence Posts: What Lasts Through Clark County's Wet Winters

Rainy winters are hard on fence posts, and the material, size and setting of each post decide how long a fence stands.

Side-by-side comparison of a black powder-coated steel fence post vs a traditional wooden cedar fence post.

For steel vs wood fence posts in Clark County, WA, steel under a wood fence makes sense on a wet lot. Steel doesn't rot, though its zinc coating still wears away where it meets the soil. The right post depends on how your yard drains, what fence it carries and how it's set.

What Makes Fence Posts Fail?

Three causes show up most in failed fence posts: concrete finished below ground, undersized posts and cheap materials. Gene and his crew see these most often on local jobs.

Fence post rot does its worst at the ground line. Wood that isn't rot-resistant decays fastest there, where soil moisture and air both reach it (Lebow and White, USDA Forest Products Laboratory, 2007).

They build against all three. On a Terek Fencing job:

  • Concrete finishes with a beveled top that sheds water.
  • Posts are true 4x4s instead of 3.5 by 3.5 inches.
  • Rails are treated or cedar 2x4s instead of plain fir.
  • Boards are thicker.

Steel vs Wood Fence Posts Side by Side

Metal vs wood fence posts fail in different ways. Wood rots at the soil line. Galvanized steel fails when its zinc coating wears away underground and the steel starts to rust.

FactorTreated wood postsGalvanized steel posts
How it failsRots at the soil lineZinc wears off in the soil, then the steel rusts
What sets its lifeVaries with the treatment, the post size, how it's set and how wet the ground staysLasts until the zinc wears through, which happens faster in wet, acidic soil
Weak spot in wet groundConstant moisture feeds rotWet, acidic soil speeds zinc loss
Best fitWood fences on well-drained lotsWet lots, under a wood fence or chain link
What to ask forTreated posts in a true 4x4 sizeThe coating weight and the steel gauge

Sources: American Galvanizers Association, 2011; Lebow and White, USDA Forest Products Laboratory, 2007.

Why Clark County Rain and Soil Are Hard on Posts

Vancouver gets most of its rain from October through March (NOAA NCEI 1991 to 2020 normals, Vancouver Pearson Airport):

  • Yearly total: 37.47 inches, with 28.05 inches, about 75%, falling in those six months.
  • Winter: December through February averages 15.18 inches.
  • Wettest and driest months: December at 6.07 inches, July at just 0.42.
  • Early January: measurable rain on about two of every three days.

Where the soil holds water, as a lot of Clark County's does, that rain stays against the posts.

What makes soil hard on posts:

  • Clay and silt hold water, so they stay poorly drained and short on air (American Galvanizers Association, 2012).
  • Acidic soil speeds zinc loss on steel (AGA, 2011).
  • Dense, wet soils are hardest on zinc, and sandy, coarse soils are easiest.
  • Neutral or slightly alkaline ground is where zinc does best.

To check your own yard:

  1. Look up your property in the USDA Web Soil Survey.
  2. Note its drainage class.
  3. Note its steel corrosion rating. That rating measures how the soil can corrode or weaken uncoated steel, which is why a steel post's zinc coating matters.
Traditional pressure-treated 4x4 wood post attached to horizontal 2x4 rails and cedar pickets.

What Decides How Long a Post Lasts

A post's life depends on what it's made of and how wet its ground stays. Wood fails when it rots, and galvanized steel fails once its zinc wears away.

Wood Posts

A wood post lasts as long as it can hold off rot. Moisture, air and temperature govern how fast decay fungi work, and at the ground line, a post in Vancouver's wet soil gets both moisture and air (Lebow and White, 2007).

  • What rot needs: decay fungi need wet wood, above 20 to 25% moisture content (Lebow and White, USDA Forest Products Laboratory, 2007).
  • Deep in the soil: low oxygen holds back most decay fungi, which is why the damage shows up near the surface.
  • What to ask for: pressure treated fence posts in a true 4x4 size.

Galvanized Steel

PostMaster posts and the pipe under a post on pipe are galvanized, so a zinc coating protects the steel from rust (AGA, 2012). The zinc works two ways: it shields the steel, and it corrodes first in the steel's place, so the steel underneath stays sound until the zinc is used up.

  • Coating thickness: a thicker zinc layer takes longer to wear through (AGA, 2012).
  • G90 coating, used on PostMaster posts: about 0.76 mils of zinc per side, where a mil is a thousandth of an inch (AGA, 2013).
Rot-resistant black steel post installation for long-lasting cedar privacy fencing.

Steel Posts Under a Wood Fence

A steel post under a wood fence suits a lot that stays wet through Vancouver's October-to-March rains, because steel can't rot in the ground. Three types of metal fence posts for wood fences keep the wood out of the soil:

  • PostMaster posts
  • Square metal posts
  • Posts on pipe

The boards and rails stay wood. PostMaster posts are shaped to hide behind them.

Steel posts still sit in wet soil, so the zinc coating matters. ASTM F1043, the industry standard for steel fence frames, covers wood fences as well as chain link.

PostMaster Steel Posts

PostMaster fence posts are galvanized steel posts that Master Halco makes for wood fences. Master Halco says the steel won't rot, twist or warp, and that it's easier to hide than a standard post and bracket setup (Master Halco product data). Its spec (section 32 31 29) lists:

  • Steel: ASTM A653 sheet steel with a 50,000 psi yield strength
  • Coating: G90 zinc
  • Shape: made so the boards and rails cover the post
  • Holes: punched every inch along both flanges

Posts on Pipe

A fence post on pipe is a wood post fastened to a galvanized steel pipe set in the ground. Through Vancouver's wet October-to-March months, the pipe takes the ground contact while the wood post stays above the soil, so the fence still shows wood posts above ground.

How to Set Fence Posts So They Last

When setting fence posts in concrete, Gene and his crew use a fast-setting mix and a beveled top, so the concrete doesn't finish below ground. Their method:

  • Depth: Gene's fence post depth is 2 feet on local jobs.
  • Concrete: a fast-setting post mix, such as Quikrete's, which sets in about 20 to 40 minutes. For setting fence posts in concrete, this kind of mix goes into the hole dry and is soaked with water, with no mixing needed.
  • Top: beveled, so rain runs off and away from the post.
  • Timing: the crew works year-round, setting posts in the dry windows between rains.

Before Digging: 811 and Permits

Call 811 first. Under Washington's rules, whoever does the digging makes the request (RCW 19.122.020 and 19.122.030):

  • Request a locate 2 to 10 business days before digging. Business days don't count weekends or legal holidays.
  • A contractor can file the request on the digger's behalf.
  • Mark the dig area with white lining or white flags.
  • Since January 1, 2026, digging can't start until every utility in the area has responded.
  • Locate marks expire 45 calendar days after the request, so a delayed job needs a new one.

Confirm current rules with the Washington Utilities and Transportation Commission.

Check permits.

  • Inside Vancouver city limits: a fence 6 feet tall or shorter needs no building permit (City of Vancouver).
  • Environmentally sensitive areas: a critical area review may apply.
  • Questions: the city lists eplans@cityofvancouver.us for permits and cddplanning@cityofvancouver.us for sensitive areas.
  • Other cities and unincorporated Clark County: each sets its own rules.

Confirm current rules with the City of Vancouver or your city's permit office.

Choosing a Post by How Your Lot Drains

Steel posts suit a poorly drained lot, and treated wood suits a well-drained one.

  • Lot rated poorly drained in the Web Soil Survey: steel posts under the wood fence.
  • Well-drained lot: treated wood posts in a true 4x4 size, set in concrete with a top that sheds water.
  • Chain link: steel in a galvanized or black vinyl-coated finish.
  • Cedar fence: Grade 1 cedar, with tight knots that don't fall out, or clear cedar boards on treated or cedar 2x4 rails, over the post type your drainage calls for.

Plan Your Fence With Terek Fencing

If you're weighing steel vs wood fence posts for your yard, Gene and his crew can walk the lot and recommend the right posts. Terek Fencing's fencing services lead with wood and chain link, including steel posts under wood fences.

Every install carries a 2-Year Workmanship Warranty that covers rechecking shifted posts, adjusting sagging gates and replacing loose fasteners. If an existing fence already has rotted or leaning posts, the crew handles repairs too. Contact Terek Fencing for a free on-site estimate.

Frequently Asked Questions

Are metal posts better than wood for a fence?

On a wet lot, yes: steel posts avoid the rot that ends wood posts at the ground line. How long a steel post lasts then depends on its zinc coating and how wet and acidic the soil is.

Can you build a wood fence on metal posts?

Yes. The posts change to steel, and the boards and rails stay wood. PostMaster posts are made for wood fences, and posts on pipe keep a wood post above the soil.

Do steel posts show on a wood fence?

Not with PostMaster posts, which Master Halco makes to hide behind the boards and rails. With a post on pipe, the steel pipe is in the ground and the post you see is wood.

How deep should fence posts be set?

Gene and his crew set fence posts 2 feet deep in fast-setting concrete on local jobs. Whoever digs must call 811 at least 2 business days ahead, as Washington law requires.

Should fence posts be set in concrete?

Yes, as long as the concrete sheds water. Concrete finished below ground is a common cause of failed posts, so give it a sloped top that carries rain away.

How long do fence posts last?

A wood post lasts until rot at the ground line weakens it, so its treatment, its size, how it's set and how wet the ground stays decide how long that takes. Galvanized steel lasts until its zinc wears through, and that happens faster in wet, acidic soil.